From 41 listings to one verdict

One illustrative Columbus search at a 7.0% cap floor, followed from the results page to an offer, plus how a flip or a wholesale deal is priced.

  1. Set a minimum return before you search

    For Buy & Hold, a minimum cap rate or rent-to-price ratio; for Fix & Flip and wholesale, the most you’d pay as a share of after-repair value. Add a location, price range, beds and baths.

    In the Columbus example, 41 homes are listed in range and 6 come back.

    How to search a market by cap rate

    Your return threshold Required
    7.0
    0.90

    Key · Columbus, Ohio

    Listed in your price range41
    Cleared your 7.0% cap floor6
    The other 35 never load
    Values
    listing comps, active & off-market
    Rents
    rental comps, checked against HUD & Census
    Flood
    FEMA
    Growth
    FHFA

    Illustrative listings; figures made up.

  2. Read the band before the cap rate

    ScoutScore bands every result for free, reading rent against comps and days on market. In this example three homes band Strong, two Fair and one Weak, and the Weak one, 88 Weyant Ave, has the third-highest cap of the six.

    Strong 3
    • 915 E Hudson St 8.1% Rent sits mid-range in five close comps
    • 2204 Cleveland Ave 7.8% Four bedrooms at $214,500
    • 1428 Maplewood Dr 7.4% Relisted lower; rent low in its comp range
    Fair 2
    • 560 Hamilton Rd 7.3% 13 days on market · expect competing offers
    • 77 Bryden Rd 7.1% 47 days · room to offer under ask
    Weak 1
    • 88 Weyant Ave 7.5% Rent already at the top of its comps

    Illustrative listings; figures made up.

  3. Underwrite the one you pick

    Tap Analyze on 1428 Maplewood Dr. A first read shows up within seconds, and the full report comes back in less than a minute: 74 out of 100, a Buy, at medium confidence.

    Ask what a lower offer or a tougher rent does; the answer comes back with the deal’s numbers recalculated. The first 5 questions on a deal are free.

    Buy & Hold · 1428 Maplewood Dr ScoutSense
    74/100 Buy Confidence Medium
    Cap rate 7.4%
    Cash flow $244/mo
    DSCR 1.24
    • Deal narrative
    • Risk register
    • Negotiation target
    • Exit strategy
    • Comps
    • Confidence & caveats

    Powered by ScoutSense AI · illustrative listing, at 25% down and 7.0%

  4. See what to offer, and why

    The report’s negotiation target is the offer it suggests. It starts at the asking price and comes down for each point of leverage the listing gives you, such as an earlier listing that didn’t sell at a higher price, a long time on market or an older house. You see each deduction in dollars.

    Here it comes to $199,000 against $206,900 asking. At that price the cap rate is 7.7%, up from 7.4%. Your walk‑away is $217,000, the most you can pay and still get a 7.0% cap.

    Suggested offer · 1428 Maplewood Dr Buy Medium confidence
    Asking price
    $206,900
    Failed at $214,900, relisted lower
    −$2,835
    Rent estimate range ±10%
    −$2,069
    Built 1972: inspection allowance
    −$3,000
    Rounded to the nearest $500
    +$4
    Suggested offer
    $199,000

    Cap rate 7.4% at the asking price → 7.7% at the suggested offer

    “It failed at $214,900 and came back at $206,900. The rent band is wide and the house is from 1972, so leave room for the inspection.”

    Your walk‑away for a 7.0% cap: $217,000

    Illustrative example. The listing, its history and the figures are made up; the adjustments follow the product’s own rules.

  5. For a flip or a wholesale deal, the offer starts from ARV

    The ARV comes from comparable homes. You see each one’s address and type, and the homes we left out. On a flip, the report puts the cash buyer’s price first: 70% of the ARV, minus repairs.

    If you wholesale, your assignment fee comes off as well. What’s left is your max offer, shown against the asking price.

    Fix & Flip · if you wholesale
    ARV, from comparable homes
    $260,000
    70% of ARV
    $182,000
    Estimated repairs
    −$35,000
    Cash buyer’s price
    $147,000
    Your assignment fee
    −$10,000
    Your max offer
    $137,000

    Asking $149,900 is $12,900 over your max offer

    Illustrative flip. The figures are made up; the steps follow the product’s own rules.

  6. Keep the search running and send the report

    Keep up to four scenarios per deal, such as the suggested $199,000 against $206,900 asking. The search stays saved and emails new matches daily or weekly. The PDF and a pre-filled, non-binding offer letter go out under your brand on the Team plan.

    1. Scenario saved Suggested offer $199,000 against $206,900 asking cap 7.4% → 7.7%
    2. Saved search Columbus rentals · checked daily · each match as its own email Cap ≥ 7.0%
    3. Exported Analysis report (PDF) with the scenario · offer letter at $199,000 PDF · LOI

    Illustrative listings; figures made up.

  7. Run step one on your own market

    500 credits on signup, no card. Each new home in your results and each full underwrite spends credits.